Scotland have gone a long way under Steve Clarke. The shot that sealed their greatest journey certainly did. Kenny McLean was inside his own half when he let fly, a 50-yard shot in the play-off against Denmark to book a 3,000-mile flight across the Atlantic. McLean’s was the third wonder goal Scotland scored on one astonishing evening; Lawrence Shankland’s close-range finish was rather overshadowed by Scott McTominay’s overhead kick and Kieran Tierney’s long-range curler even before McLean added his injury-time entry to the goal-of-the-game contest.
It tapped into Scotland’s rich history. There have been tragicomic failures, a perennial inability to get out of the group, but also the moments of brilliance that lend hope. Scotland’s first World Cup in the Americas featured the goal that – with apologies to McLean, McTominay and Tierney – surely still ranks as the greatest in their country’s colours; Archie Gemmill’s slaloming strike against a Netherlands team who nevertheless reached the 1978 World Cup final, but only after losing to Scotland. “Ally’s army” nonetheless failed to conquer Argentina, manager Ally McLeod’s confidence looking more like delusion.
Now a Miami meeting with Brazil promises to evoke memories of their 1982 meeting and the David Narey thunderbolt that put Scotland ahead. The Scots were to lose 4-1 and to exit a third consecutive World Cup on goal difference.
All of which may have a pertinence again. Scotland are in a pool with 2022 semi-finalists Morocco and perennial contenders Brazil. Scotland and the Selecao seem drawn to each other: this is a fifth meeting and a stalemate in 1974 brought the Scots’ only point. Morocco beat them 3-0 in 1998, when such a scoreline could rank as more of a surprise.
Logic may suggest Scotland’s best chance of progressing is among the better third-placed finishers, involving having a respectable goal difference and beating Haiti. Scotland’s past indicates that is no guarantee: they drew with Iran in 1978 and lost to Costa Rica in 1990. They enter their ninth World Cup with just four wins so far: against Zaire, as they were called then, in 1974, Netherlands in 1978, New Zealand in 1982 and Sweden in 1990.
But those at least came in days when qualifying was the norm. Part of the reasons why scenes of unbridled joy greeted November’s play-off victory over Denmark was that Scotland had become strangers to global occasions. Only one country had played in at least eight World Cups, but none in the 21st century: Scotland. After qualifying for six out of seven, they reached none of the last six.
Now Clarke is compiling a case to be the most successful Scotland manager of all. It is based largely on lesser stages, but no one else has taken Scotland to three major tournaments. They went two decades without qualifying for anything until Clarke changed a pattern of decline.
The qualms about him concern in part his record in the biggest games. Scotland took one point each in Euro 2020 and 2024; they were arguably the worst side in the latter. They only scored one goal in each, from Callum McGregor and McTominay respectively. Scotland’s last victory in a tournament remains the 1-0 against Switzerland in Euro 96; the man who earned it, Ally McCoist, will be in the United States this summer, but as a pundit in his sixties.
Should Clarke fail to end Scotland’s wait, either for a win or to finally reach the knockout stages of anything, it would bring into question the SFA’s wisdom in giving him a new four-year contract. But he has brought common sense, continuity and a common bond.
Playing in a World Cup is in itself the culmination of something. For the captain Andy Robertson and his deputy John McGinn, each in his thirties, both among their country’s most capped players, it is likely to be the only one. Neither peaked in either of their European Championships but Aston Villa’s Europa League-winning skipper has had arguably the best season of his career, the Napoli Scudetto MVP McTominay the best two years.
Clarke has a core of solid citizens, with a dash of youth. The 19-year-old Findlay Curtis was his youngest choice, until Billy Gilmour was ruled out and Tyler Fletcher, a veteran of just 17 minutes of league football, was called up.
They drag the average age down, but this is still one of the oldest squads in the tournament. The oldest of all, Craig Gordon, has lived through three Scotland World Cup campaigns. The 43-year-old goalkeeper was born a mere six months after Narey stunned Brazil, at least until Zico and co responded.
There is, of course, a still older man of Scottish heritage who could cast a shadow over the World Cup. If the Tartan Army seem certain to provide a welcome addition to the tournament – and, while a kilt or two may have been seen in Boston over the years, the chances are that they have been worn rather less in Miami – it has also been shaped by the man with a Scottish mother. Though in the good humour and self-deprecating wit of the supporters, the down-to-earth nature of Clarke’s players, their collective commitment to gradual improvement and a relatively modest aim of reaching the last 32, there may be little of this Scotland in Donald Trump.
