Paris Saint-Germain’s Champions League semi-final with Bayern Munich delivered in spades on Tuesday night, with the European heavyweights serving up a 5-4 classic in the first leg.
A blistering first half saw holders PSG establish a 3-2 lead, following a stunning display of attacking football with momentum swinging between the two sides.
Khvicha Kvaratskhelia and Joao Neves put PSG 2-1 in front after Harry Kane had opened the scoring for Bayern from the penalty spot. After Michael Olise pulled Bayern back level, PSG re-established their lead when Ousmane Dembele converted a controversial penalty just before the break.
The second half continued in a similar vein with PSG looking like they were pulling away when Kvaratskhelia and Dembele put them 5-2 up on the night, only for Dayot Upamecano and Luis Diaz to reduce the deficit to one ahead of next week’s second leg.
While some have criticised the defending of both sides, others have been quick to laud the match as one of football’s greatest games.
Here, Daily Mail Sport reporters reveal their pick for the greatest game they have attended – and why it should be considered among the best to have been played…
PSG earned a 5-4 victory over Bayern Munich on Tuesday in a Champions League classic
The match has been hailed as one of football’s greatest games after a feast of attacking football
Oliver Holt
Liverpool 3-3 AC Milan (3-2 on pens), 2005 Champions League final
Liverpool were so completely outclassed by AC Milan in the first half that it was embarrassing but the second half, which started with Liverpool 3-0 down, took on an other-worldly quality.
Driven on by a titanic performance from Steven Gerrard, I will never forget the look of bewilderment on the faces of some of the Milan players as Liverpool recovered to 3-3.
The match had everything, including a late, astonishing double save from Jerzy Dudek to deny Andriy Shevchenko. That was when I knew Liverpool were going to lift the trophy.
It really was the Miracle of Istanbul.
Steven Gerrard titanic performance inspired the Miracle of Istanbul as Liverpool fought back from 3-0 down against AC Milan before winning on penalties
Ian Ladyman
Argentina 3-3 France (4-2 on pens) – 2022 World Cup final
These games are never good. The occasion? Yeah, that’s amazing. But the football? Not so much.
This was the one that broke the mould. This was the game when one world superstar – Kylian Mbappe – scored a hat-trick and still lost. This was the game when another – Lionel Messi – finally put the seal on a life’s work.
France – fresh from a sickness bug that had ravaged their squad – played like they needed a lie down for the first hour. Messi scored an early penalty and then Angel Di Maria put the finishing touches on an end-to-end move that looked to have won his team the title.
But France’s comeback was such that only a save from Emi Martinez from Randal Kolo Muani in the 123rd minute prevented the 2018 winners winning an incredible game 4-3 and defending their crown.
Argentina eventually took it on penalties. They deserved it, too. Just about.
Argentina and France delivered a stunning World Cup final in 2022, which ended with Lionel Messi putting the seal on a life’s work by lifting the trophy
Kylian Mbappe became just the second man to score a hat-trick in the World Cup final, but ended up on the losing side
Craig Hope
Inter Milan 4-3 Barcelona, May 2025
The greatest game I’ve ever watched will always be Liverpool 4-3 Newcastle from 1996. But one more recent game that stands out, for which I was in attendance, is Inter 4 Barcelona 3 in last year’s Champions League semi-final second leg, after a 3-3 draw in the first leg.
The noise is guaranteed in the San Siro, but here we had the amplification of events on the pitch. Barca thought they’d won it when Raphinha scored in the 87th minute, and so did I! But a 93rd minute equaliser took us to extra-time before Inter’s Davide Frattesi won it for the hosts.
It was sensational drama, made all the better by the fact it was a second leg and the prize was a place in the final. That is the one downside of the PSG-Bayern belter this week, it was a first leg, and only next week will the true jeopardy be apparent.
Inter Milan’s 4-3 win over Barcelona in last season’s Champions League semi-final second leg had delivered sensational drama
Jack Gaughan
Man City 2-1 Liverpool, January 2019
There is an honourable mention for an eight-goal thriller between City and Monaco in 2017 but for sheer quality, two teams at the peak of their powers, this title clash had it all.
Jurgen Klopp’s rock against Pep Guardiola’s classical. Liverpool had only conceded eight goals all season until that point but chances rained down at both ends.
A night of tension, anxiety, two stunning City goals from Sergio Aguero and Leroy Sane, with Roberto Firmino’s equaliser wonderfully crafted. Ederson made a top late save to preserve the points.
Just like Arsenal’s trip to the Etihad Stadium the other week, it was a game that truly lived up to the billing of the country’s best teams going at it.
Man City’s 2-1 win over Liverpool in 2019 showed two title contenders at the peak of their powers
Kieran Gill
PSG 5-4 Bayern Munich, April 2026
Recency bias be damned, how can I not plump for PSG 5-4 Bayern?
I was writing the match report, and when Harry Kane scored his 54th goal of the season for his club, I thought it was lovely, because it gave me an early storyline to work with on whether winning the Champions League this season could be the Ballon d’Or moment he has been waiting for. Turns out, that was only the beginning.
What followed was chaos. Beautiful chaos. I was trying to type, but not take my eyes off the match, because doing so risked missing something special.
The Premier League, with its obsessions over long throws and set pieces and defending and time-wasting, could only dream of such a spectacle.
Harry Kane’s 54th goal of the season was just the start of the beautiful chaos of PSG’s 5-4 win over Bayern Munich
Tom Collomosse
Germany 0-2 Italy, July 2006
Two European heavyweights and three-times world champions. A brilliant stadium. High-class players everywhere you looked. An ending for the ages.
Long before Fabio Grosso scored Italy’s opener with a minute of extra-time remaining, this game had developed into a classic.
Michael Ballack on one side, Andrea Pirlo on the other. Miroslav Klose against Fabio Cannavaro. Jens Lehmann and Gigi Buffon in goal.
Perhaps Italy’s 4-3 win over West Germany in Mexico in 1970 was even better… but as I was not born for that one, the 2006 epic has my vote.
Fabio Grosso’s extra-time goal came towards the end of a classic World Cup semi-final, with Alessandro Del Piero scoring Italy’s second moments later to beat Germany
Matt Barlow
Portsmouth 7-4 Reading, September 2007
It was September 2007 and I suspect the quality did not match the Parc des Princes on Tuesday night… but I was at Fratton Park to report on this wild goal spree, and it always springs to mind when there is another high scoring game.
That’s the thing about football. You don’t always need quality for a thrillingly memorable game.
There was a hat trick for Benjani, two own goals, a penalty and in Harry Redknapp and Steve Coppell two managers committed to entertaining the fans.
Benjani scored a hat-trick as Portsmouth beat Reading 7-4 in the Premier League’s highest scoring game back in 2007
‘Difficult to analyse,’ mused Coppell drily afterwards.
There were eight goals in the second half, the old Fratton timbers were shivering and plenty of confusion in the press box about who created the goals and how exactly.
It remains more than 18 years on the highest scoring game of the Premier League era.
