The hand that rocks the cradle.
Warning: Spoilers ahead! Do not proceed unless you’ve watched “Euphoria” Season 3’s second episode, “America My Dream.”
Before the second episode of “Euphoria” Season 3 aired, Sydney Sweeney’s OnlyFans baby outfit was already getting backlash. Viewers slammed it as “disgusting” when the shocking image was shown in the trailer.
Sunday’s episode, “America My Dream,” reveals the context for it — and it doesn’t make series creator Sam Levinson look better. The whole debacle shows how he lost the plot.
In the episode, Cassie (Sweeney) poses for photos while she’s dressed in a diaper, holding her legs open, wearing a sheer pink top and pigtails, sucking a pacifier. Her intention is for the photos to be “sexy.”
Later, Cassie shows the baby photo shoot to a friend, explaining that she did it to cater to a “whole subculture…adult babies.” She keeps getting “all these requests” for it, she says.
As she explained in the season premiere, she’s doing these photo shoots to make money on OnlyFans, to pay for a $50K floral arrangement she wants for her wedding with Nate (Jacob Elordi).
On-screen, other characters call it “sick” and “disturbing.”
So, the show doesn’t act like it’s acceptable. But, just acknowledging that isn’t enough. Who is this visual of Cassie dressed as a baby for? If Levinson has a point other than shock value, he misses it by miles.
It’s fine for a show to be provocative, but this goes beyond that. It’s such a loaded image — one fan commented, “that’s some pedo sh-t” — it’s irresponsible for Levinson to present it with minimal comment, without interrogating it.
In an interview published April 12, the showrunner told the Hollywood Reporter that Cassie’s OnlyFans outfits are supposed to have “absurdity” and “humor” and also be “depressing.” But there are thousands of other outfits that could convey that. It didn’t need to be a baby.
In Season 2, Cassie degraded herself for Nate. The show did seem to take too much pleasure in it. But, there was a larger point, as that story explored how a girl like Cassie can destroy herself for a toxic guy. That’s an experience that many viewers can relate to, or can recall witnessing.
When Cassie dresses as a baby in Season 3, “Euphoria” isn’t saying anything thoughtful about a particular experience. It isn’t asking us to understand her behavior. It’s making her a sordid punchline, to the point where it feels spiteful.
“Euphoria” premiered in 2019, before its stacked cast — Zendaya, Sweeney, Elordi — became A-listers. The first two seasons followed the hedonistic antics of high schoolers.
At first, the question of “who is this for?” turned out to be nearly everyone. When Season 2 aired in 2022, it became HBO’s second most-watched show after “Game of Thrones,” boasting over 18 million viewers.
It resonated beyond Gen-Z because it encouraged Gen X and millennial audiences to recall their own teen experiences, since it was packed with older pop culture references that weren’t realistic for Gen-Z (like characters wearing Halloween costumes from “Taxi Driver” and “True Romance”).
When Season 3 puts Cassie in a baby outfit, it’s hard to see who that’s supposed to resonate with — aside from creeps.
During the 2023 Cannes Film Festival, Levinson was asked about the sexual content in his shows. He replied, “We live in a very sexualized world. The influence of pornography is really strong in terms of the psyche of young people.”
Sure, that’s a thought. And he’s not going anywhere with it in Season 3, aside from vaguely gesturing at it, and showing off the fact that he’s seemingly familiar with porn. Congratulations on that.
Season 3 is full of porny “fetish” content visuals — like Cassie dressed as a dog while Nate tugs her leash — with nothing to say beyond, “look at this!”
“Euphoria” has always been a provocative show, but its first two seasons also had some deeper meaning. In Season 3, the provocation is just empty outrage-bait.
