If the New York Knicks win it all this year, just remember a high school student called it six years ago and has the receipts to prove it.
Evan Pfeufer, a Long Island resident, opted for an unconventional entry in his 2020 Smithtown High School West yearbook.
While his classmates listed their academic awards, extracurricular activities and sports accolades in the high school yearbook, Pfeufer’s portrait was accompanied by just six words: “Knicks in 6. 2026 NBA Finals.”
The prescient prediction has gained significant traction after he shared photos on social media in recent days, with one Instagram post alone amassing over 130,000 views.
The Knicks lead the San Antonio Spurs 2-1 in the best of seven series. They dropped Game 3 Monday night, with President Donald Trump making the first appearance by a sitting president at an NBA championship game. The teams play again Wednesday at Madison Square Garden.
Pfeufer, now 23 and in sales, said he wanted to use the yearbook to make a bold declaration about his beloved Knicks, who he concedes were “terrible” at the time – The Knicks finished the 2020-21 season with a record of 41-31.
“I was at my good buddy’s house and I said, ‘Knicks, six, 2026’,” he said. “It rhymed so well that I just figured, all right, I’m gonna put that there.”
“I could have said Knicks in 5, 2025, or Knicks in 7, 2027,” he added. “I guess I got the right year.”
Pfeufer said he took some grief, particularly from his parents, for not using the yearbook space to spotlight his school achievements, which included being a member of the honor society.
“I kept it just as the quote because I thought that if it happened, it would look way better than if I had a bunch of awards underneath,” he says.
Pfeufer says his parents have since come around to his thinking.
“Now that it’s happening the way it is, they said for the first time in their lives, ‘Alright, you were right’,” he said.
Early in the playoffs, the lifelong Knicks fan said he swore off watching the team’s games because every time he tuned in, they lost. Since they’ve reached the finals and his prediction is inching closer to reality, he’s been watching them at home with family.
Pfeufer believes the current squad has what it takes to win the franchise’s first NBA title since 1973 — even if it isn’t in six games.
“I absolutely love that they play ethical basketball,” he said. “It’s team basketball. Everyone knows their role and cares so deeply, and you can see it whenever they play. They have heart.”
