No sooner had Ben Stokes been declared unfit for the series finale against India than thoughts turned, in something close to blind panic, to the Ashes. Because if the last few weeks have confirmed anything, it’s that England will be hard pressed to beat Australia without him.
Bazball would be declared dead even before it had faced its ultimate challenge, and the Australian media – still high-fiving each other after England’s churlishness on the final evening in Manchester – would go into overdrive. It hardly bears thinking about.
Yet the restructuring of the team for the fifth Test at The Oval provided an unsettling glimpse of the future: with England understandably keen to field four seamers on a green-looking surface, the absence of Stokes has created an imbalance solved only by the dropping of Liam Dawson, the team’s lone frontline spinner.
Dawson might have been omitted in any case after sending down 62 overs for a single wicket on his return to Test cricket at Old Trafford, an experience that included a very public one-to-one tutorial from Stokes as England walked off at tea on the last day. But what if Stokes breaks down again during the Ashes, leaving an unbearable onus on Shoaib Bashir, the 21-year-old off-spinner who would then form a crucial part of a four-man attack? Again, the scenario is unthinkable.
But it’s not as if it was unforeseeable. Stokes has bowled 140 overs in this series, 23 more than his previous-heaviest workload, in his debut series in Australia in 2013-14. Throw in 11 overs against Zimbabwe in May, and he has not endured a heavier home summer since 2017, when he played in seven Tests rather than five.
All the while, his body has creaked and groaned, becoming a story in its own right, much as Denis Compton’s knee did in the 1950s. The kneecap was eventually removed and sent for safekeeping to Lord’s, where it lives in a biscuit tin – a curious memory of a more innocent time.
Ben Stokes declared himself unfit for England’s decisive final Test against India due to injury
Stokes has bowled 140 overs in this series, 23 more than his previous-heaviest workload
Stokes has put himself through the wringer so vigorously, so often, that his list of ailments is a little longer: two operations on his left index finger, surgery on his left knee, hamstring trouble and now a grade-three tear of a right shoulder muscle.
That’s before any mention of the break he took to look after his mental health in 2021. He has put body and soul on the line for his country, and his body has rebelled once more. Clearly, he knows no other way.
Even so, should he have taken things easier?
During India’s first innings at Lord’s, England’s bowling coach Tim Southee was sent down to the boundary by the pavilion to suggest Stokes remove himself from the attack after one long spell. In the second, with the game on the line, he followed a burst of nine overs with one of 10: talisman meets Superman.
Then, in Manchester, he bowled eight overs in a row on the final morning, and clutched his right arm in pain after every delivery. Inspirational and selfless, certainly. But was he pushing his luck? Later, he outlined his philosophy: ‘Pain is just an emotion.’ It turns out pain is rather more than that.
Stokes being Stokes, he has no regrets. ‘When I’m out on the field, I play to win and give everything I possibly can,’ he said, attending the pre-match press conference as if he, not stand-in Ollie Pope, were still in charge.
He has put himself through the wringer so vigorously and so often, but knows no other way
When Stokes is missing, the 11 other England players seem inadequate to cover all bases
‘If I feel there’s a moment in a game where I need to put everything I’m feeling aside, I’ll do that because it’s how much this team means to me, how much playing for England means to me, how much winning means to me. Being a professional sportsman, injuries are part of this game and I can’t do anything about that.’
Stokes’s absence has created room, at long last, for Jacob Bethell, who now has the chance to prove why England were wrong to ignore him for the first four Tests.
But it also picked at the scab that periodically troubles this team. When Stokes is missing, 11 players seem inadequate to cover all bases.
And if his rehab extends beyond the 10-week upper limit outlined by England, and drifts towards the first Ashes Test at Perth on November 21, that scab could become a full-blown wound – one from which his team may struggle to recover.
