The league table never lies, apparently. It may do now. A supposed title decider ended with the side still in second nevertheless possessing the advantage. It has been Arsenal’s title to lose for months, but perhaps this defeat means it is being lost.
They had retreated down the tunnel at the Etihad Stadium as Manchester City went on their lap of honour, a bare-chested Erling Haaland letting his hair run free, Pep Guardiola directing kisses to the crowd, Gianluigi Donnarumma beating the badge on his chest, relieved the biggest error of his season had become a footnote, not the faulty footwork that determined the destination of the trophy.
This, perhaps, was what Arsenal feared. Second best against City in the Carabao Cup final, they will be second behind them on Wednesday, if Guardiola’s team beat Burnley. “It is a new league now,” admitted Mikel Arteta.
An epic game delivered a massive momentum shift to Manchester. In their last four matches against domestic opponents, Arsenal have lost to City twice, Southampton and Bournemouth. In their last four fixtures, City have beaten Arsenal twice, Liverpool and Chelsea. They are peaking when it matters. “We are alive,” said Guardiola, who had warned it would be all over with defeat. “I’m happy because we can extend the hope.”
Where there was Haaland, there was hope. City had the big man for the big occasion. Three years ago, Haaland – along with Kevin de Bruyne – decided a similar clash with Arsenal. History repeated itself when the striker contorted his giant frame to hook in a shot.
He had hit the post earlier. He had not scored in the Premier League for two months. He has had a barren 2026 but his last two home games have yielded a hat-trick against Liverpool and now this, perhaps the most seismic of his 158 City goals.
He was too much of a handful for Gabriel Magalhaes, who ripped his shirt tugging the Norwegian and somehow escaped a red card for aiming a headbutt at him. “I think if I fell on the floor, which I will not do unless someone really attacks me, it will maybe be a red card,” said Haaland. His honesty did not cost City. But Arsenal, the supposed defensive masters, were frayed in other respects, caught crucially on a counter-attack.
The talismanic Nico O’Reilly, Arsenal’s Carabao Cup final nemesis, was his provider, with a low cross after running the ball out from his own half. A move begun by Donnarumma – this time his distribution was good – was finished by Haaland. He was there at the end, too, hoofing the ball clear from the edge of his own box. It amounted to a marauding display. “Today he fought like an animal,” said his captain, Bernardo Silva.
Donnarumma had particular grounds to be grateful to the warrior-striker. The goalkeeping error in the Carabao Cup final came from Arsenal and it was costly. This stemmed from City, but it was not. Kai Havertz scored a Champions League final winner against them, but when it seemed he had delivered a goal of a similar magnitude in the Premier League, Haaland ensured otherwise. “The difference was in both boxes,” lamented Arteta.
Each had scored from inside them as they traded goals in 107 seconds. Rayan Cherki, who had already hit the post, weaved his way between Gabriel and Declan Rice, and angled his shot in off the far post.
But Arsenal were bolder than many expected. They did not come just to nullify and Arteta used their physical power to press high. It yielded a remarkable goal. Havertz charged down Donnarumma’s clearance, the ball flying in. It was a reminder Donnarumma is no Ederson, no typical Guardiola goalkeeper. It revived the old criticism about his shortcomings with the ball at his feet. “The mistake from Gigi is our mistake,” said Guardiola. He could be forgiving because the Italian was to have a redemptive second half: a superb save from Havertz, the quick ball out that led to City’s second goal.
Which rendered it tougher for an Arsenal side who have only scored four times in six games. They scarcely fashioned their latest effort with creativity. And yet they were agonisingly close to more.
Havertz was denied by Donnarumma. Eberechi Eze struck one post with a shot, Gabriel the other with a header that deflected off O’Reilly. Havertz headed just over in the 95th minute. They could scarcely have come closer. “The margins,” sighed Arteta. “We hit the post [with Eze], I look at the images, it is incredible how the ball doesn’t go in.”
Part of the frustration for him may be that Arsenal were far better than they were against Bournemouth and that he did much right. Choosing both Eze and Odegaard added flair; one almost scored, the other nearly assisted. Havertz looked a vast upgrade on the dropped Viktor Gyokeres. And yet it still was not enough.
Guardiola, his boss for three-and-a-half years, can still be the boss when it matters. The business end of the season often brings the best from him. The strangest, too. He had slapped his thighs in irritation.
He went through his repertoire of extraordinary – at times, indescribably weird – gestures on the touchline. When he complained Gabriel did not see red, he got his seventh yellow card of the campaign. He may get his seventh Premier League title.
Arteta’s first could remain elusive. “We go again,” he said. But they may be second again.
